When Getting Healthcare Depends on Luck

When Senator Marielle Smith gave birth to her son Benjamin, she felt like an 'Amazon warrior'. But in the weeks that followed, she was in pain, anxious and wondering if she was failing as a mother.

In this episode of Regarding Me, I'm joined by Marielle, who now chairs the Senate Select Committee on Women's Health. We talk about what happened after she brought Benjamin home, why finding the support she needed involved so much luck, and how listening to women's experiences can help improve healthcare.

Listen to the full episode with Senator Marielle Smith

Why didn't anyone tell me it could be this hard?

Marielle felt prepared for childbirth. She'd heard the stories, knew it would be painful and understood what to expect. In fact, her birth experience was better than she'd imagined.

What she hadn't expected was how difficult things would become afterwards. Breastfeeding was incredibly painful. She developed recurrent mastitis and postnatal anxiety, and felt increasingly isolated.

She remembers asking herself:

"Is it normal that this is so hard? Am I uniquely failing in this?"

For Marielle, the pressure to breastfeed and do the best for her baby became tangled up with feeling that she might be failing him.

We talk about how expectations of motherhood, and the stigma surrounding difficulties after birth, can make women reluctant to admit they're struggling.

Marielle makes an important point about talking more openly before problems arise. Women don't need to be frightened about what might happen, but knowing what support is available and where to find it could make an enormous difference when they need help.

When getting help is another challenge

I asked Marielle how she managed to advocate for herself when she was already exhausted, unwell and anxious.

She'd tried different breastfeeding services and appointments, but the advice didn't always work once she got home. Even leaving the house with Benjamin could feel overwhelming. And support wasn't necessarily available when she needed it. She didn't get a place in a mothers' group until Benjamin was five months old.

Eventually, she found a lactation consultant who could visit her at home. The consultant sat with Marielle, saw how much pain she was in and listened to what she wanted. She didn't judge her or insist that she continue breastfeeding. She reassured Marielle that stopping was an option while supporting her wish to keep trying.

As Marielle put it:

"she saw me, she saw what I was going through, she listened to me."

I asked whether the difference was that the consultant understood what Marielle wanted to do, rather than simply telling her what she thought was best.

Marielle explained how important it was for someone to understand why breastfeeding mattered so much to her, while also reassuring her that it would be okay if things didn't work out.

It's an important distinction. Being listened to means having your own needs, concerns and preferences taken seriously.

Why should healthcare depend on luck?

With the consultant's support, Marielle was able to breastfeed Benjamin for a year, something that was deeply important to her. But she also recognised how fortunate she'd been. She could afford home visits. She lived in Adelaide, where the service was available. She had family support that helped make it possible. Not every woman has those options.

Marielle talks about the differences in postpartum services depending on where women live, what they can afford and when support becomes available. She also raises a bigger question: if women need particular care at a particular time, what happens when that care simply isn't there?

This is about more than individual women knowing what questions to ask. The services and support need to be available when women actually need them.

How can sharing women's experiences improve healthcare?

Marielle's experience stayed with her. She wanted postpartum healthcare to improve, and she pushed for a Senate inquiry.

The Senate Select Committee on Women's Health now has a broader remit, including postpartum care, women's pain, medical misogyny, fertility, medical devices and systemic issues affecting women's healthcare.

Marielle also explains what she means by medical misogyny. She's talking about the structures, research, funding and practices that can disadvantage women, rather than assuming that individual healthcare professionals are deliberately treating women badly.

One of the things we discuss is how personal experiences can become evidence for change. At the time of our conversation, the committee had received more than 2,000 submissions.

Marielle explains that women don't necessarily need to write a formal research paper to contribute their experiences. A submission can be as straightforward as a letter explaining:

  • What went well?

  • What didn't?

  • What would you want to change?

We also talk about the options for protecting privacy when sharing sensitive experiences.

The committee can’t itself implement changes to healthcare. Its role is to gather evidence and make recommendations to governments and others who can act on them.

That's why listening to women's lived experiences is so important. Individual accounts can help reveal patterns that might otherwise be missed.

And there's another benefit to speaking openly. Marielle talks about how, once women begin sharing difficult experiences, others often feel able to talk about what happened to them too.

We need to hold the mother as well as the baby

Towards the end of our conversation, I ask Marielle what she'd say to women who are struggling to get the care they need. We talk about how many women find it easier to advocate for their children than for themselves.

But Marielle also turns the responsibility towards the people around them:

"we need to hold the mother as well as the baby."

That includes families, communities and the healthcare services women rely on.

It's a reminder that women shouldn't have to carry the entire responsibility for finding the support they need, particularly when they're already dealing with pain, illness or exhaustion.

Thank you, Marielle, for being so open about those difficult weeks after Benjamin's birth, and for helping us understand how women's experiences can be used to make the case for better healthcare.

Listen to my full conversation with Marielle.

Next
Next

Does asking questions make you a difficult patient?